top of page

5 Common Mental Performance Tips That Can Backfire

Kate Allgood
3 days ago
11 min read

Athletes frequently hear advice like "just be confident," "relax," "stop overthinking," or "forget about the mistake." While these statements are usually intended to help, they can sometimes create more pressure, frustration, or self-doubt. The problem isn't necessarily the advice itself, but that it tells athletes what they should think or feel without giving them a practical way to get there. Effective mental performance training goes beyond encouragement. It helps athletes understand what's happening internally, recognize how it's affecting their performance, and develop skills to respond intentionally when things become difficult.


Cyclist riding a road bike, illustrating how common mental performance tips can backfire for athletes.

Why Can Common Mental Performance Advice Backfire?


Mental performance advice can backfire when it creates an expectation about how athletes should feel without providing a process for what to do next. Instead of helping athletes navigate pressure, it can leave them trying to control thoughts, emotions, or physical responses that aren't always under their direct control.

Most advice in sports comes from a good place. Coaches want athletes to trust their abilities. Parents want their children to enjoy competing rather than becoming overwhelmed by pressure. Teammates want to encourage one another after mistakes. The intention is rarely the problem.


The difficulty is that encouragement and instruction aren't the same thing.

Imagine an athlete struggling during competition. They're frustrated, questioning themselves, and beginning to hesitate. Someone tells them to relax, be confident, and stop thinking so much. The athlete understands what they're being asked to do, but they may have no idea how to accomplish it.


They already want to feel confident. They don't want to be nervous or caught up in their thoughts. Being reminded of how they should feel can sometimes make them even more aware of the gap between their current experience and the one they believe they need.


This is where seemingly helpful advice can become another internal demand. Rather than directing attention toward the performance, the athlete starts trying to fix themselves.


Understanding this distinction changes how we approach several of the most common phrases athletes hear.


1. Why Doesn't "Just Be Confident" Always Help Athletes?


Telling athletes to be confident can be unhelpful because confidence isn't something they can simply switch on. When confidence is low, trying to force it can shift attention toward evaluating how they feel rather than focusing on what they can do.


Confidence is often treated as a requirement for good performance. Athletes are encouraged to believe in themselves, trust their abilities, and approach competition with certainty. Those experiences can certainly support performance, but they aren't always available when athletes need them most.


Consider a hockey goalie who has allowed two early goals. Their confidence has dropped, and they're beginning to question their positioning and reactions. A coach tells them, "You've got this. Just be confident."


The goalie may appreciate the encouragement, but it doesn't necessarily help them with the next shot. They might begin thinking about whether they feel confident enough, whether another goal will go in, or what the coach will think if they struggle again.


Their attention moves further away from reading the play, tracking the puck, and responding to what is happening.


The more useful approach is to give athletes something specific to work with. For that goalie, it might be returning attention to tracking the puck, maintaining appropriate positioning, or reading the developing play. These are things they can actively engage with, regardless of whether confidence has returned.

This doesn't mean confidence is unimportant. It means athletes don't have to wait for confidence before they can perform.


Over time, learning to respond effectively when confidence is low can also help develop self-trust. Rather than relying entirely on the belief that things will go well, athletes begin trusting their ability to respond when things don't.


2. Why Can Telling an Athlete to "Just Relax" Make Things Worse?


Telling athletes to relax can increase frustration when they interpret tension or nervousness as something that must disappear before they can perform. Trying to force relaxation may make them more aware of the very sensations they're attempting to control.


Competition naturally involves activation. Heart rate increases, muscles prepare for action, breathing changes, and attention becomes more sensitive to what is happening. These responses aren't automatically signs that something is wrong.

Yet athletes often learn to interpret nervousness as a problem. They assume that if they feel tense, their performance will suffer, so they begin trying to eliminate the sensation.


Imagine a tennis player preparing to serve at an important moment. They notice their heart beating faster and their arm feeling tighter than usual. Someone tells them to relax.


Now the athlete may become even more focused on their body. They check whether their arm feels loose enough, try to slow their heart rate, and become frustrated when the tension doesn't immediately disappear.

What began as a normal response to an important moment has become something else to worry about.


There are times when regulating activation is useful. Breathing strategies, physical routines, and other self-regulation skills can help athletes adjust their internal state. But the goal shouldn't always be to eliminate activation.


Sometimes the more helpful response is recognizing that the body is preparing for something demanding and learning to perform while those sensations are present.

A useful question might be, What does my body need right now, and what does this moment require?


That gives athletes a way to respond rather than making complete relaxation a condition for performing well.


3. Why Doesn't Telling Athletes to "Stop Overthinking" Work?


Telling athletes to stop overthinking identifies the problem but doesn't give them a useful direction for their attention. Trying to suppress thoughts can sometimes make athletes more preoccupied with whether they're thinking too much.


Overthinking is common when athletes feel pressure to perform well. They may begin analyzing movements that normally happen automatically, questioning decisions, replaying mistakes, or anticipating what could go wrong.


A golfer who usually swings freely might start thinking about several technical details while standing over the ball. A basketball player might hesitate because they're considering every possible outcome before making a decision.


From the outside, the solution seems obvious: stop thinking and trust your training.

But the athlete may not know how to do that.


When someone says, "Stop overthinking," the athlete may begin monitoring their thoughts even more closely. They try to determine whether they're thinking too much, whether their mind is quiet enough, or whether they've successfully stopped analyzing.


Once again, their attention has shifted toward controlling their internal experience.

The alternative isn't necessarily to stop thinking. It's learning how to direct attention more effectively.


For the golfer, that might mean returning attention to the target and committing to the shot. For the basketball player, it could mean reading the defense and responding to the available opportunity.


Thoughts may still appear. The athlete doesn't need to eliminate every one of them. They need to recognize when their attention has become caught up in unnecessary analysis and intentionally return it to the demands of performance.

That is a skill athletes can practice, rather than an instruction they're expected to follow automatically.


4. Why Can "Forget About the Mistake" Be Unhelpful?


Telling athletes to forget a mistake can be unhelpful because it doesn't address the meaning they've attached to what happened. Athletes may continue thinking about an error when it feels connected to their ability, opportunities, or how others see them.


Mistakes are inevitable in sport, but they don't all carry the same meaning.

For one athlete, missing a shot is simply part of competing. For another, that same mistake might become evidence that they're having a bad game, aren't good enough, or are letting their team down.


The difference isn't necessarily the mistake itself. It's how the athlete interprets it.

Imagine a soccer player who loses possession and the opposing team scores. Their coach tells them, "Forget about it. Next play."


The instruction makes sense. The player needs to remain engaged in the game. But internally, they may still be thinking about the error and what it means. Perhaps they're worried about being substituted or disappointing their teammates.

Simply telling them to forget doesn't necessarily change that interpretation.


A more useful approach is helping athletes recognize when they're caught up in the meaning of a mistake and understand how it's influencing their attention and behavior.


During competition, that process may need to be brief. The athlete might notice they're replaying the error, recognize that they're becoming hesitant, and redirect attention toward their next responsibility.


Later, they can reflect more fully on what happened, what they can learn, and whether their interpretation was helpful or accurate.


Moving on from a mistake doesn't mean pretending it didn't happen. It means learning how to recover attention and continue participating without allowing the mistake to define everything that follows.


5. Why Doesn't "Just Stay Positive" Always Improve Performance?


Telling athletes to stay positive can create additional pressure when they believe negative thoughts or difficult emotions shouldn't be present. Effective mental performance isn't about maintaining positive thoughts at all times, but learning how to respond to thoughts and emotions without automatically being controlled by them.


Positive thinking can be useful. Encouraging self-talk, constructive perspectives, and optimism can all support athletes in different situations.


The problem arises when athletes believe they must remain positive regardless of what they're experiencing.


An athlete might feel disappointed after a poor performance, frustrated with their progress, or uncertain about an upcoming competition. Those responses aren't necessarily inappropriate. They may reflect something important to the athlete.

If they're repeatedly told to stay positive, they may begin judging themselves for having those experiences.


I shouldn't be thinking like this. I need to change my attitude. Why can't I be more positive?


Now they're not only dealing with the original difficulty but also evaluating their reaction to it.


A more helpful approach involves recognizing thoughts and emotions without immediately labeling them as good or bad. Athletes can explore what those experiences are communicating, whether the meaning they're attaching is useful, and how they want to respond.


For example, frustration might reveal that something matters deeply to them. Self-doubt might reflect uncertainty about an unfamiliar challenge. Disappointment might indicate that an outcome didn't align with their expectations.


None of those experiences automatically determines what the athlete does next.

The goal isn't to replace every uncomfortable thought with a positive one. It's to develop enough awareness and flexibility to choose a useful response, even when the internal experience is difficult.


What Should Athletes Do Instead of Trying to Think or Feel Differently?


Athletes benefit from having a process that helps them recognize what's happening, understand how it's influencing them, choose an intentional response, and re-engage with what the moment requires. This provides something practical to work with rather than another mental state they're supposed to achieve.


Across all five examples, the underlying problem is similar. The advice describes an outcome—confidence, relaxation, clear thinking, emotional recovery, or positivity—but doesn't necessarily explain how to navigate the experience that is getting in the way.


Mental performance training helps bridge that gap.


A useful starting point is learning to recognize what's happening internally. An athlete might notice that they're becoming frustrated, hesitant, overly analytical, or preoccupied with an outcome. Rather than immediately trying to eliminate the experience, they begin by acknowledging it.


The next step is understanding its influence. What meaning have they attached to the situation? Has their attention shifted away from the task? Are they trying to protect themselves from another mistake or control something that isn't entirely within their influence?


From there, they can make a more intentional choice about what matters now.

For some athletes, that might involve a breathing strategy to regulate activation. For others, it may mean shifting attention toward a specific task, adjusting their perspective, or committing to an action despite uncertainty.


Finally, they re-engage with performance.


This process won't guarantee that athletes always feel confident, calm, or positive. It gives them a way to participate effectively without requiring those experiences first.


And that's an important distinction. The goal of mental performance training isn't to create a perfect internal state. It's to help athletes develop the skills to work with themselves across the different conditions competition brings.


How Can Parents and Coaches Give More Helpful Mental Performance Advice?


Parents and coaches can support athletes by combining encouragement with specific direction, helping them identify what they can influence and what to do next. The most useful response often depends on whether the athlete needs reassurance, practical guidance, or simply someone to listen.


A coach who notices an athlete becoming hesitant might provide a clear performance cue rather than simply telling them to be confident. A parent supporting an athlete after a difficult competition might acknowledge their disappointment before asking whether they want to talk about what happened.

The goal isn't to turn every interaction into a mental performance lesson.


Sometimes a simple expression of support is exactly what an athlete needs.

But when practical guidance is appropriate, it helps to make the next step clear.

Instead of "Just relax," a coach might remind an athlete to use a familiar breathing routine or return attention to their preparation. Instead of "Stop overthinking," they might direct the athlete toward one relevant cue. Instead of "Forget the mistake," they can help the athlete identify their next responsibility.


The most important shift is moving away from telling athletes what they should feel and toward helping them develop the skills to respond.


Over time, that also gives athletes greater ownership of their mental performance. Rather than depending on someone else to tell them to be confident or calm, they become better equipped to recognize what they need and respond independently.


Final Thoughts

Most mental performance advice is well-intentioned. Coaches, parents, and teammates want athletes to feel confident, recover from mistakes, and compete without becoming overwhelmed by pressure. The difficulty is that telling someone how they should think or feel doesn't necessarily give them the skills to make that happen.


Athletes need more than encouragement to be confident, relaxed, focused, or positive. They need to understand their internal experience, recognize how it influences their attention and behavior, and develop practical ways to respond.


That doesn't mean every thought or emotion needs to be analyzed. Sometimes the most useful response is simply recognizing what's happening and returning attention to the task. Other times, athletes benefit from exploring the meaning they've attached to a situation or learning how to regulate their activation.


The larger objective is to develop a relationship with themselves that allows them to navigate these experiences rather than constantly trying to eliminate them.

Because mental performance isn't about always feeling the right way. It's about learning how to work with yourself, whatever the moment brings.


Ready to Develop a More Reliable Mental Game?


Through one-on-one mental performance coaching and The Athlete Within® App, Quantum Performance helps athletes understand their internal patterns, strengthen attention, build self-trust, and develop practical skills for responding to pressure, mistakes, and uncertainty.

Learn more about mental performance coaching or explore Quantum Performance.


Frequently Asked Questions


What are common examples of unhelpful mental performance advice?

Common examples include "just be confident," "relax," "stop overthinking," "forget the mistake," and "stay positive." These statements aren't always harmful, but they can be incomplete when athletes don't have the skills or understanding needed to act on them.


Why doesn't positive thinking always work for athletes?

Positive thinking can be helpful, but trying to force positive thoughts may increase frustration or self-monitoring. Athletes benefit from learning how to respond effectively even when difficult thoughts or emotions are present.


What should athletes focus on when they're struggling mentally?

Athletes can begin by recognizing what's happening internally and identifying what they can influence. Directing attention toward the next relevant action or responsibility is often more useful than trying to force a particular feeling.


How can coaches help athletes who overthink?

Coaches can provide clear, task-relevant cues and help athletes redirect attention toward the demands of performance. This gives athletes something specific to focus on rather than simply instructing them to stop thinking.


Can mental performance skills be trained?

Yes. Skills involving attention, self-regulation, awareness, and intentional responses can be developed through consistent practice. Like physical and technical skills, they become more reliable when athletes train them regularly rather than only attempting to use them under pressure.


About Quantum Performance Inc.

Quantum Performance Inc. provides mental performance coaching for athletes based in San Diego, California, working with athletes across the U.S. and internationally through both in-person and virtual coaching. Learn more at https://www.qpathlete.com.


About Kate

Kate Allgood holds two master's degrees in psychology and has more than 16 years of experience working with athletes on mental performance. A former professional hockey player and Division I captain, she has worked with high school, college, Olympic, and professional athletes, as well as professional sports organizations, including the San Diego Gulls, the former primary minor league affiliate of the Anaheim Ducks.


Her work focuses on helping athletes better understand themselves, strengthen their internal skills, and develop greater consistency and freedom in performance. While Kate has graduate training in applied sport psychology and general psychology, she is not a licensed psychologist and does not diagnose or treat clinical disorders.


Disclaimer

The information provided is not to dispense medical advice or prescribe the use of any technique, either directly or indirectly, as a form of treatment for physical, emotional, or medical problems, without the advice of a physician. The information provided is only to offer information of a general nature to help you in your quest for high performance. If you know or suspect you have a health problem, it is recommended you seek your physician's advice.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page